J.W. ponders whether he is not getting everything out of his statistics class in his post Who needs skills, my TI-83 thinks for me.
Basically, what it boiled down to, is my STA 2023 class is really only teaching me how to pick out which statistic for the calculator to run, and how to interpret the results ? it might be teaching other people, who use 4-function calcualtors, or who don?t know how to do the more advanced stuff, how to calculate some things by hand, but by and large, I?ll have gained very little practical knowledge from this class.
I had a recent experience along these lines myself.
My daughter had me buy her a calculator for her math class a few weeks ago. The homework that she brings home has exercises that instruct, “Use your calculator to…” However, the math is easy enough that she should be able to do in her head.
The other night, she asked me for some help.
“Dad, I don’t get this. Can you explain what I need to do?”
So I had a look at the problem and then started to ask her questions to get her to realize how to visualize the problem in her head. She said to me, “Well, we are supposed to use the calculator to figure it out.”
It became clear to me that the part of the brain that should have been conceptualizing the problem and how to come about the answer had turned off. She was simply trying to figure out how to make the calculator give her the answer and didn’t know where to begin.
So I said, “Let’s put the calculator aside for now. How would you do this problem without it? You’ve got 30 of this and need to distribute them equally to 5 people…” I had to pull her into a problem solving frame of mind. It took a couple of minutes to get back into the right groove, and she solved the problem. Now we pulled the calculator out and we solved the problem using it, but only after she understood what mathmatical operation was required.
I think overzealous application of technology in education does students a disservice. Too much of the focus goes into using the technology, which distracts from the subject matter at hand.
There is the notion that it’s not the destination, but the journey that matters most. When you give people the Internet and Google, where is the journey? I met an educator and counselor back in April and she told me that her students have no idea how to do research and how to use a library and books to get the information they need for their papers. She said the biggest problem is that they become frustrated because it takes too long. They just want to do a search on the net, find the information, and then cut and paste. They don’t want to read books, take notes, formulate the ideas and express them in their own words.
Like… Oh-my-god… that’s so like my parents generation… Eeeew! I don’t have time to actually read a book AND be instant messaging my friends.
Posted: October 26th, 2005 under Uncategorized.
Comments: none